Research / primary records and open questions
An investor case study: Lisa Peterson's evidence
Follow a court-described representation to a surviving financial exhibit, while keeping the missing connection between those records visible.
Edited by the Theranos Film project · Briar assisted · . Editorial draft; not independently fact-checked. About this independent project · Corrections and review history.
Current evidence status
Primary-record case study; delivery and reliance history incomplete
What the appellate opinion records
The amended opinion places Peterson among 2014 C-2 investors and recounts her testimony that financial documents received from Holmes and Balwani projected $230 million profit by the end of 2015. This is the court's account of trial evidence, not her complete transcript or investment file.
Sources and inspection limits
- United States v Holmes and Balwani: order and amended opinion, 22 December 2025 · Original source
Appellate judicial opinion recounting trial evidence · Printed pp11–13 / PDF pp11–13; Peterson and financial evidence; cover identifies amended date
Selected cover and factual-background passages, not a full appellate/legal-status audit. A judicial account of selected trial evidence is not a complete witness transcript, investment file or cash ledger. Do not infer the current status of every proceeding.
A matching number is not proof of delivery
Exhibit 15031 includes a July 2014 internal email and projections containing $230 million 2015 net income. This numerical match does not establish that this exact version was delivered to Peterson, when she received it, its accompanying qualifications or the decisions it influenced.
Sources and inspection limits
- United States v Holmes: Trial Exhibit 15031, internal email and financial attachment · Original source
Public trial exhibit: internal email, projections and reported balance sheet · PDF p1 email dated 15 July 2014; p2 HOLMES0019226; p3 HOLMES0019227; p4 HOLMES0019228
Email metadata extracted; all three financial pages visually checked on 21 November 2026. Company-produced statements, not an independent audit. Proforma/forecast figures are not actual expenditure; internal transmission does not establish delivery to an investor.
What this already clarifies
A financial forecast is explicitly about a future period. A claim that a proprietary instrument already performs a test is about present capability. An investment pitch can contain both, and uncertainty in the forecast does not automatically qualify the separate technical representation. Establish actual delivery and reliance before explaining why this investor invested.
Sources and inspection limits
- United States v Holmes: trial Exhibit 3696 · Original source
Contemporaneous presentation / trial exhibit · PDF page 3; page 8 reviewed earlier
Page-level inspection, not the full delivery history. Wording is evidence of a representation, not demonstrated capability, authorship, delivery to a particular investor or all accompanying qualifications.
The evidence chain—and its missing link
| Record | What it establishes here | Still missing |
|---|---|---|
| Appellate account of Peterson's testimony | A court-described forecast representation received from the executives. | Full testimony and exact investor-facing attachments. |
| 15 July 2014 internal email, Exhibit 15031 | A particular financial version circulated internally. | Proof that this version reached Peterson, when, and with which qualifications. |
| Surviving technology presentation, Exhibit 3696 | Wording presenting a testing capability. | Investor-specific delivery and a dated, validated demonstration. |
| Investment decision | Requires its own transaction and reliance records. | Verified entity, dates, amounts and decision evidence. |
Provisional conclusion
This is a useful primary-record case study, not yet a complete reconstruction of a particular investment. It shows why forecast risk, present capability and actual reliance need separate treatment. A matching dollar figure does not close the delivery gap.
Inspect the financial records and arithmetic · Present versus future claims · Investor chronology
What is still needed
- Peterson's full testimony and the exact admitted investor-facing exhibit versions.
- Dated delivery emails, meeting notes, demonstrations and oral qualifications.
- The actual investing entity, payment records, decision process and information relied on; do not infer motives or identify a family solely from a secondary shorthand.
- A checked film passage addressing this investor or these representations. The film is not a substitute for the transaction file.
Read the curated dossier JSON · Inspect the full source register